Judge orders statewide recount in school superintendent race

2012-12-08T08:45:00Z 2012-12-11T14:45:31Z Judge orders statewide recount in school superintendent raceBy TRISTAN SCOTT of the Missoulian missoulian.com
December 08, 2012 8:45 am  • 

KALISPELL – A Flathead County district judge on Friday ordered a statewide vote recount in the race for Montana schools superintendent, ruling that Republican Sandy Welch’s narrow defeat to Democrat Denise Juneau may have been the result of voting machine errors and departures from election law.

“Certain votes might not have been properly counted, and the right to vote and to have that vote recorded is a fundamental right,” said Flathead County District Judge Stewart Stadler. “No harm can come from a recount, especially when the applicant is expected and charged the costs of the recount.”

Welch resides in Martin City, so legal jurisdiction for the manual recount lies in Flathead County.

Official results had Juneau winning the seat by a 2,231-vote margin out of the nearly 468,600 ballots cast in the Nov. 6 election, but Welch argued that widespread voting machine errors and a host of other Election Day foibles were grounds for the recount, and may reverse the outcome in her favor – particularly given vote counting problems in Lewis and Clark, Yellowstone, Missoula and other counties.

A recount also may reveal shortcomings in the state’s election process and lead to more uniform practices, she said.

“I really hope that the kinds of errors we’ve seen this time around, which the court has recognized as kind of systemic and widespread, that they are all resolved and that we make sure the integrity of our election system is strong and that every Montanan can rely on it to ensure that every vote is counted,” Welch said following the judge’s order.

Montana law gives candidates the right to request a recount if their margin of victory is one-half of 1 percent or less, and Juneau won by approximately 0.48 percent.

Still, Welch remained hopeful.

“We believe that the kinds of errors that we are seeing are systemic enough that it does overturn the outcome,” Welch said.

Attorneys representing Juneau and Secretary of State Linda McCulloch, the state’s chief election officer, announced their intent to appeal Stadler’s decision to the Montana Supreme Court, as well as to request a stay in the recount pending the high court’s consideration of the appeal.

Kalispell attorney Amy Eddy, who represents Juneau in the case, said Welch furnished no evidence in her application that votes had been improperly counted, but rather drew repeated inferences – based on alleged mishaps in a smattering of precincts – that widespread errors may have occurred.

“The practical effect of the judge’s decision creates a very dangerous precedent, because it would allow any unsuccessful candidate to come to court and argue that votes were improperly passed in one particular county, and that would therefore entitle them to a statewide recount,” Eddy said.

***

Stadler said state election law requires that the recount must occur within five business days of his decision, and ordered Welch to deposit a bond of $115,000 by Tuesday. The bond is meant to fund the manual recount efforts by election officials in each of the state’s 56 counties.

Welch could have automatically forced a recount by making a formal request to Secretary of State Linda McCulloch, the state’s chief election officer. Instead, she elected to bring the matter before Stadler, who was charged with finding “probable cause” that an erroneous count occurred before ordering the recount.

Welch’s 17-page application for the recount outlined numerous examples of alleged vote counting errors, including ballots jamming in electronic counting machines, election officials re-marking ballots that were run through machines multiple times with Sharpie markers, mending “spoiled ballots” with stickers rather than giving voters a replacement ballot, and ballots that weren’t officially stamped.

“This court does not find anywhere in election law that allows stickers or Sharpies to be used to correct mistakes on ballots,” Stadler said. “The election laws require that new ballots be filled out.”

Stadler stressed that state law merely requires him to determine whether or not there exists probable cause that violations occurred – namely, that votes cast were not correctly counted – and not to determine the extent of the violations.

“The court does not have the authority to determine whether these violations are substantial or material. If I was I would probably find that they are not material. But they are violations,” he said.

Jorge Quintana, chief legal counsel for McCulloch, said the mere specter of human and mechanical error should not trigger a court-ordered recount.

“Your honor, the vote is about the closest to sacred thing we have in our secular society. And it should take more than assumptions and allegations, more than the ghosts of partial jams and partial counting to overturn the actions of the local election administrators,” Quintana said. “The election administrators did their job, they acted reasonably and they followed the law. This is not probable cause.”

Welch said the state and national Republican parties will help pay for the recount, as well as individual donors, whose identity will be reported to the state political practices commissioner.

Listed as lead counsel on Welch’s application is James Bopp of Terre Haute, Ind. A prominent lawyer, Bopp has successfully attacked campaign finance limitations throughout the nation. He was one of the original lawyers for Citizens United, the group whose legal challenge led to the landmark 2010 U.S. Supreme Court ruling that said corporations and unions can spend money directly from their treasury to influence elections.

Welch said Bopp is the lawyer hired by the Republican National Committee to work on the case, but another attorney from his firm, Anita Woudenberg, delivered arguments Friday.

Reporter Tristan Scott can be reached at (406) 531-9745 or at tscott@missoulian.com.

Copyright 2015 missoulian.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(7) Comments

  1. zootown
    Report Abuse
    zootown - December 09, 2012 11:58 am
    Nothing like a poor loser to "whine our kids in schools".
  2. MTNimrod
    Report Abuse
    MTNimrod - December 08, 2012 5:21 pm
    And did you lose by a margin of less than .5%? You seem awfully bitter about losing an election in the 90's. When in the 90's? Are we talking closer to 10 or closer to 20 years ago?

    Idiot Democrat....
  3. MTNimrod
    Report Abuse
    MTNimrod - December 08, 2012 5:16 pm
    I couldn't agree more, Gc - unfortunately, your remarks may be a case of "pearls before swine".
  4. seagull
    Report Abuse
    seagull - December 08, 2012 8:31 am
    Review our state election results, Mr Bopp. Montanans clearly repudiate your statement , "The average voter couldn't care less who's "funding" a campaign.
  5. idiot state
    Report Abuse
    idiot state - December 08, 2012 7:49 am
    Good luck. The tip of the iceberg, one would guess, and voting fraud is no doubt widespread in that heavily unionized state. On election night all neighboring states had tallied their votes, but Montana never has seemed to be able to get the voting thing right. Not till the next day did some results become known. It's a backward (and impoverished, and unionized) state but there's no reason why the voting can't at least aim to be somewhat legal.
  6. Got concrete
    Report Abuse
    Got concrete - December 07, 2012 10:32 pm
    It said there were malfunctioning machines and a recount is within her rights. Stop the 8th grade insults and try to approach a subject from an adult perspective, would ya'?
  7. montanamuralist
    Report Abuse
    montanamuralist - December 07, 2012 8:56 pm
    Of course the judge is from the most conservative county in the state and the "problem" counties are primarily Democratic. No harm in a recount with an election this close but really should have some evidence.......that means facts right wingys.....before a judge sets a precedent like this. So we will see but really makes the GOP look like their typical selves...all whine and no facts. No evidence of voter miscounts. Just saying it "may have happened. Wish I would have known that was ok when I lost an election in the 90's.....haha...just say it "MAY" have happened and that gets you a recount. Idiot Republicans....
Missoulian Civil Dialogue Policy

Civil Dialogue Policy for Commenting on Missoulian.com

We provide this community forum for readers to exchange ideas and opinions on the news of the day. Passionate views, pointed criticism and critical thinking are welcome. Comments can only be submitted by registered users. By posting comments on our site, you are agreeing to the following terms:

Commentary and photos submitted to the Missoulian (Missoulian.com) may be published or distributed in print, electronically or other forms. Opinions expressed in Missoulian.com's comments reflect the opinions of the author, and are not necessarily the opinions of the Missoulian or its parent company. See the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy for more information.

Our guidelines prohibit the solicitation of products or services, the impersonation of another site user, threatening or harassing postings and the use of vulgar, abusive, obscene or sexually oriented language, defamatory or illegal material. You may not post content that degrades others on the basis of gender, race, class, ethnicity, national origin, religion, sexual orientation, disability or other classification. It's fine to criticize ideas, but ad hominem attacks on other site users are prohibited. Users who violate those standards may lose their privileges on missoulian.com.

You may not post copyrighted material from another publication. (Link to it instead, using a headline or very brief excerpt.)

No short policy such as this can spell out all possible instances of material or behavior that we might deem to be a violation of our publishing standards, and we reserve the right to remove any material posted to the site.

Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick

Silver's Lagoon fish stocking

Fish are stocked in Silver's Lagoon at McCormick Park in preparation for children's fishing derbies.

The 4:06 – trending topics and hot headlines

The 4:06 – trending topics and hot headlines

Missoulian reporter Rob Chaney presents the latest news you need to know about today's headl…

The 4:06 – trending topics and hot headlines

The 4:06 – trending topics and hot headlines

Missoulian reporter Kate Haake presents the latest news you need to know about today's headl…

The 4:06 – trending topics and hot headlines

The 4:06 – trending topics and hot headlines

Missoulian reporter Martin Kidston presents the latest news you need to know about today's h…

The 4:06 – trending topics and hot headlines

The 4:06 – trending topics and hot headlines

Missoulian digital director Emily Foster presents the latest news you need to know about tod…

Visual note-taking at Asia-Montana Energy Summit

Visual note-taking at Asia-Montana Energy Summit

Watch visual note-taker Alece Birnbach record a 90-minute seminar on global energy in 21 sec…

The 4:06 – trending topics and hot headlines

The 4:06 – trending topics and hot headlines

Missoulian reporter Kate Haake presents the latest news you need to know about today's headl…

The 4:06 – trending topics and hot headlines

The 4:06 – trending topics and hot headlines

Missoulian digital director Emily Foster presents the latest news you need to know about tod…

The 4:06 – trending topics and hot headlines

The 4:06 – trending topics and hot headlines

Missoulian digital director Emily Foster presents the latest news you need to know about tod…

Deals & Offers

loading...

Search our events calendar