HAMILTON – A Hamilton man was charged with deliberate homicide Friday after a fight provoked by a night of drinking Black Velvet and Diet Pepsi in a downtown motel left his common-law wife brain dead.

Douglas Charles Reynolds, 47, is being held in the Ravalli County jail on $250,000 bail.

His common-law wife, 40-year-old Jessica Hawkins, was removed from life support and died in a Missoula hospital late Tuesday.

According to an affidavit filed by Ravalli County Attorney Bill Fulbright, Reynolds told Hamilton police that he “freaked out” when he awoke in Deffy’s Motel “to find a dead wife” in the room on Sunday, Nov. 11.

In a series of interviews, Reynolds told an escalating version of the events that transpired during two nights of drinking and fighting in the motel room – “arguments that caused enough noise and commotion that the motel owner purposely did not place any patrons in the rooms adjoining defendant and Ms. Hawkins on the night of (Saturday) Nov. 10,” according to the affidavit.

At 9:25 a.m. on Sunday, Ravalli County 9-1-1 received a phone call from the motel’s front desk, reporting an unresponsive female.

Hawkins was found on the floor of the motel room, just outside the bathroom door, breathing but unresponsive. “Red-colored vomit had dried in a flow pattern from her mouth down her cheek,” the affidavit said.

Reynolds initially claimed that Hawkins had no alcohol in her system, but after a short time admitted that she had been drinking the previous night. Blood tests at Marcus Daly Memorial Hospital in Hamilton revealed a 0.342 BAC.

Reynolds’ own BAC was 0.252.

The emergency room examination found that Hawkins had suffered a traumatic brain injury, and had a large subdural hematoma and swelling of the brain – as well as other bruises and injuries on her chest, biceps, hips and legs. She was airlifted to St. Patrick Hospital in Missoula, where doctors determined that she was clinically brain dead.

At first, Reynolds told Hamilton police officers that his wife “becomes volatile” when she drinks, and had yelled at and hit him with a phone book. He had “simply taken control of Ms. Hawkins by the arms and held her down,” according to the affidavit’s retelling.

Later, though, Reynolds admitted that he “snapped,” and hit Hawkins in the left temple with his right elbow. He also admitted hitting her with an open hand on the right side of her head, and then giving her another drink, the affidavit said.

Reynolds claimed that he went to bed at 11:30 p.m., while Hawkins watched television. He said that he found her on the floor, snoring, in the morning. He went to the front desk, he said, when she wouldn’t wake up.

In a subsequent interview, though, Reynolds said that he had moved an unconscious Hawkins from the bed to the floor, believing that she would “smother” in the bed. He went to the front office to call 9-1-1, he said, because he “freaked out.”


After learning that Hawkins was brain dead, Hamilton police officers returned to the downtown motel to secure what was now a homicide scene, Fulbright said in his affidavit. However, the motel staff had already cleaned the room.

The housecleaners reported finding a pillow case with blood on it, but said it had already been laundered. During a later search of the room, an officer found a pillow that appeared to have a fluid stain on it.

Officers also located and seized an empty vodka bottle, a broken pair of women’s glasses, a men’s coat with what appeared to be blood stains on the sleeves, a telephone book and two 2-liter bottles of Diet Pepsi. Additionally they observed a Black Velvet whiskey bottle in plain view in Reynolds’ vehicle.

Fulbright said further neurological testing was conducted to confirm that Hawkins was brain dead on Tuesday and she was removed from life support. The Montana State Medical Examiner’s Office will be conducting an autopsy and examination.

On Friday, Reynolds was charged with felony deliberate homicide. His bail has been set at $250,000 and, if released, he must wear an alcohol monitoring device. Reynolds is set to appear in Ravalli County District Court on Dec. 5 or 6 at 9 a.m.

Reporter Julia Cummings can be reached at 363-3300 or at julia.cummings@ravallirepublic.com.

More from missoulian.com

(5) comments


I agree with pl Deffy's Motel should have called the police. It's getting to the point where people should be ashamed to say they live in the Bitterroot Valley. This is a haven for drunks, child molesters, rapists, spouse killers. and every know deviant out there. I guess it's just another day in Montuckey.

Tommy Waters
Tommy Waters

I agree. For such a small population things are really bad here. And the Police act all keystone cops all of the time as proven by their lack of professional evidence gathering in this case. It's almost like they purposely didn't want to gather the evidence. And now the guy is going to get out on bail? This smells of cover-up all over it.


Deffy's Motel should be held 'accountable', in part, for the death of this woman. WHY would they simply allow 'buffers' of empty rooms next the fighting couple and not call the police? What would Deffy's Management require to get it to make the call? Even a layman can see that The Motel is at fault to a large degree, but THAT will come out when the jury reaches it's verdict, and rest assured, it will. After a woman is taken to the emergency room, airlifted from Marcus Daily hospital to Saint Patricks hospital and declared brain-dead the police come back? And boy was that motel staff swift. Blood was found on the pillow case (but it was laundered anyway), yet a pillow with a 'fluid stain' was left for the next happy camper to rent the room. May Deffy's close now and cease to exist as IT is also brain dead.


more death and violence brought to you by your local death ... i mean local booze distributor.bring back proabition this dangerous drug is killing people left and right ,stop the madness now.


Deffy's Motel should definitely be held as an accomplice to this woman's murder. It was so loud that they didn't book rooms next to theirs? Anyone with an ounce of decency would have called the police!! Then they rush in and launder everything in the room? Had Deffy's called police, this woman would be alive! They obviously didn't care that this woman was being beaten in one of their rooms. In fact, they condoned it by removing all other guests away from that room.
HOW can a man who has murdered someone be even considered for bail? He obviously beat this woman savagely and he is eligible for bail and nothing happens to Deffy's? More of the great Montana unjustice.
I'm surprised every murderer, drunk, child molester, and rapist doesn't move to Montana....or maybe they already have.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.